The Auschwitz trial and the question of individual responsibility
RP Kahl’s film “The Investigation” is based on Peter Weiss’s 1965 play of the same name and examines the first Auschwitz trial, which began in Frankfurt am Main in 1963 and ended in August 1965. Both the film and the play focus on the organization of mass murder at Auschwitz and the responsibility of the defendants.
Following welcoming remarks by Johannes Rudloff of the Alfred Landecker Foundation, Prof. Dr. Tobias Freimüller, Deputy Director of the Fritz Bauer Institute, and Prof. Dr. Klaus Günther, Professor of Legal Theory, Criminal Law and Criminal Procedure at Goethe University Frankfurt, took part in the discussion. The conversation was moderated by Annemarie Hühne-Ramm, Managing Director of the Hans and Berthold Finkelstein Foundation.
“I had to” – superior orders as a justification
One focus of the discussion was how defendants sought to justify their involvement in National Socialist crimes. In particular, they invoked the purported defense of having acted under superior orders (“Befehlsnotstand”): perpetrators argued that they had been required to obey orders and had no possibility of refusing them. The discussion highlighted that no such state of duress could be established in the case of Auschwitz and that refusing orders apparently would not have resulted in serious personal consequences.
The discussion also addressed how the appearance of regulated legal procedures could help obscure the crimes being committed. Invoking this kind of “sham law”, as well as supposedly inescapable chains of command, could later serve to justify one’s own actions. In this context, the panel also discussed the legal concept of Verbotsirrtum – a mistake as to the unlawfulness of an act – and the question of whether manifest injustice can be recognized without specific knowledge of the law.
From “accomplices” to a focus on crimes based on a division of labor
Another focus was the changing legal understanding of perpetration, co-perpetration and aiding and abetting. For a long time, primarily members of the highest levels of the Nazi leadership were regarded as the actual perpetrators. Many others involved were instead considered “accomplices” – even when they had actively and independently participated in killings.
In later proceedings, increasing attention was also paid to activities that enabled and sustained the functioning of the machinery of extermination. These included, for example, guard and administrative duties.
Film, theater and the representation of the Auschwitz trial
The artistic representation of the historical events was also part of the discussion. A question from the audience addressed the film as both a political testimony and a work of art. One difference highlighted between the film adaptation and Peter Weiss’s play was that, while the play deliberately presents the testimony in a sober manner and portrays its figures less as individual characters than as types, the film places greater emphasis on performance and emotional expression.
The discussion also addressed the fact that Jews as a victim group are not explicitly named in either the play or the film; in the film, a corresponding reference appears only in the closing credits. This observation led back to a fundamental question of the evening: how historical crimes can be represented artistically and how different forms of representation can open up different ways of engaging with them.
Law and responsibility
One point became clear: the legal reckoning with Nazi crimes is not only about how responsibility was assigned in the past. It continues to raise fundamental questions about how the law addresses individual actions within a criminal system and what responsibility people bear for their own actions.